Golden Age of Tech Blogging Done? I Couldn't Disagree More

I'm a big fan of Jeremiah Owyang's market analysis but I think he missed the point on this one, big time. He recently wrote a post on how the Golden Age of tech blogging is over. No way. Unless of course, he means we're about to enter the platinum age. Because things are far from dead in tech blogging-- and blogging in general. In fact, I think we're poised to enter one of the most exciting periods yet. 

I'm a big believer that tech trends tend to over-promise in the short term but under-promise in the longterm. As Jeremiah points out, the last few years demonstrated some of the limitations of blogging-- ie, we can't all make businesses and build big audiences, it won't replace all older forms of media, and  it's a grind that will wear down all but the most intent. In a lot of ways sites like Facebook, Yelp and Twitter have scratched that itch for self-expression by giving the masses an easier and more painless way to get the endorphin rush that blogging gave in the early days. Scoble speaks to that in Jeremiah's post. And that's thinned out the blogging herd-- no question.

But there are still plenty of people who love to write-- not just share, Tweet and comment-- for a living, and blogs are still the best platform for that. In many ways, professional blogging is just getting started. It's a time when new entrants are jumping into the field with bold, fresh ideas, standing on the shoulders of the blogging giants that came before, taking a second stab at reinventing the new media landscape. Look at what Bleacher Report has built in the long-neglected sports world, and what SB Nation is doing. Look at how the Verge (owned by SB Nation) is reinventing one of the oldest and most successful niches in blogging-- the gadget blog. And if you believe what you read, more new entrants are coming in the tech news category. 

Sure, a lot of the first generation have been bought up or the founders have gotten tired and are blogging less. And that's a massive loss. And, yes, that's lead to exodus of talent at some core properties.

But none of that means the medium is dead or struggling. Quite the opposite: It's ripe for a reboot and throughout the blogosphere the  next generation is sprouting up, fired up with new ideas and resolve to build exciting new businesses that are different from wave #1 from the beginning. 

Here are some of the trends this generation seems to be playing with in new ways:

- Reader blogs. Pioneered by HuffPo and SeekingAlpha, I believe we're only getting started when it comes to platforms that enable readers to blog alongside paid authors. Bleacher Report has created a fascinating business around carefully curated user blogs that other verticals may seize upon. A lot of the power of blogging is the individual voices but as we learned from blogs 1.0, there's a major distribution problem if you don't want to blog everyday. Squeaky lawsuits aside, the unpaid blogger isn't dead. Plenty of people want to write just to be read. In our world, VCs like Chris Dixon, Fred Wilson and Ben Horowitz are writing some of the best stuff out there. Imagine how many other people are out there who don't write for a living, but have plenty to say. They don't want to blog everyday, and are put off by the distribution problem if they post only sporadically. Expect a lot more innovation here. 

- UI. The Verge has really experimented with this and while it's a bit too busy for my tastes, I love that it's pushing the envelope. As blogs have exploded with volume to drive more traffic and page views, the industry has created huge challenges from a user interface perspective. A lot of the older generation of blogs have struggled to address this, as entrenched audiences have balked at dramatic changes. But there are fewer sacred cows for new properties starting with a clean sheet of paper. 

-It's definitely not all about short, commodity news. I totally disagree with Jeremiah's assertion that blogs are bound by shorter and shorter attention spans. Over the last year at TechCrunch, I wrote several very long posts and those were some of the highest trafficked on the site. If the content is good, people will find time to read. We're seeing this with the explosion of Kindle Singles and new imprints like Byliner. Writing long for the sake of long is silly, but don't underestimate a smart audience. People will read you if you do quality reporting and have something interesting to say.

- Business models. In many cases, blogs haven't yet figured out a way to monetize their influence. TechCrunch had an insane amount of reach and influence compared to any other platform for which I've written. And yet, TechCrunch made the least per ad of any platform for which I've written. There's something wrong with that, and it'll get rectified at some point. The new generation will be the ones to experiment, throw assumptions out the window and find those answers. The new generation has the advantage of starting from where the previous generation of blogs left off. The first generation did the hard part. It proved blogs had to be taken seriously; that it was possible to build a big audience, rival the biggest, most respected names in old media in terms of influence, and buid a business if you got large enough scale. The next generation will start from that premise and go further.

- Less about a Single Star; More about the Platform. One of the biggest challenges of the first generation of bloggers was building the property beyond one, dominant voice. TechCrunch did this better than many, but in the end many still viewed it as "Mike's blog." Part of that was because a lot of those blogs started as a hobby. This next generation are starting blogs as businesses first, and solving for challenges like these from the beginning. 

- Not for Sale. I can't speak for other nascent blogs out there but the biggest lesson I've learned from the first wave? Start out with a mindset not to sell. Ever. When you sell, your platform and brand may live on, but eventually your voice dies. 

Not selling can sound laughably naive in some corners of the Valley. Indeed, I've known enough entrepreneurs to know you can never know at the beginning of the journey where it'll end up. But, at least for me, I've set the expectation in every conversation I've had with potential investors and employees: If I'm going to build something, my plan is not to sell. I'm not building a non-profit. I think everyone taking the risk on my new site, me included, will make money. Lots of money. But it won't be from an acquisition, and if it is, I've failed.

That mindset is reflected in every thing a new blog does; from the way a new blog sets up compensation to the way it hires its staff and in particular, it makes the point above about platforms and individuals even more important. The only way to build a lasting media property is to build one that stands for something not someone

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Couldn't agree more.

I think we are just cracking the door on building communities at the intersection of off and online connections.

Blogging is a key to this.

And while many of us have been building communities since BBS days for enthusiasts, marketplaces as the fulfillment of this is just finding its pulse. Etsy and Ravelry and Polyvore are the few standouts at the beginning of this.

And this community bridge built on the dynamics of blogging is not just tech, its across a multitude of niche communities of interest.

Thanks for writing this.

I think future content creators won't care about this topic as much as we do.

Today some use Wordpress, others prefer an easier alternative like Tumblr, or and some are simply pointing their name.com to a Google+ account. Content creation is not dead and it's easier than ever so there will be more creators than ever.

While I do think that The Verge is a perfect example of how blogs are evolving, and how content creators are finding opportunities as older blogs get caught in drama and identiy criss, I'm not so sure you can keep replicating this (what happens when The Verge becomes today's Engadget?). The Engadgets and TechCrunchs of the world may not ever return (and that's what I think Jeremiah is pointing to) because now there are 100 posts by 100 different Android-centric blogs for every Engadget post about a new Android devices.

"Bloggers" will need to be faster, smarter, and more creative. Some will go with short, meme-ish posts with resharability, while others will opt for smarter, compreheensive, and well-researched content. There is no one-size-fits-all and there never will.

My wife could not care less about most of the blogs I visit. But she spends quite a good amount of time on Pinterest, sometimes "consuming" content I saw months ago on TechCrunch, TNW and Mashable. And this makes the less recognized bloggers less prone to blog, and younger content producers to completely bypass the blog as a whole.

Agree or disagree, blogs and bloggers are not what they used to be. The future Arringtons and Scobleizers may well never even use Wordpress.

ps. Looking forward to your upcoming venture Sarah.

At the risk of bringing up the old blog/MSM feud, a lot of those are the principles of running a magazine - paper, tablet or web ;-) (over the years I've worked on all three and some of is reinventing the wheel, some is developing a new and superior tyre. Um, metaphor stretched...)

This is a very liquid place and so the web is going to mutate many times and in many ways no one has a clue about.

All we are really talking about here is the next mutation of tech coverage is under way and I good luck on trying to figure out where it will end up next!

It all depends upon perspective. While I respect your view point Sarah, I think most of the assertions are incorrect.

To address a few viewpoints,

1) It does appear to be all about short commodity news. While you may be able to write long-form, the traffic, engagement and more of a blog is sustained by high frequency at low cost--because it's never clear what will be shared.

2) Business models
I've yet to see anything remotely close to sustaining a blog that is not at scale. It's more a place to develop yourself and your brand name...which leads to

3) The Single Star vs. Platform.
It is most certainly about the single star. I'm not sure of any branded blog platform/publication that isn't attributable to a single person's drive.
I'm here because of your name as someone I know in tech writing.
Writers now hardly write for a single publication. They write all over the place instead of building a brand. (That's bad by the way in my opinion.)

--
The only thing that I see that is changing is that there are more fragmented ways to distribute information/data/content and content can and will be consumed anywhere.

I'm not sure what a Golden Age is since many blogs didn't make money in tech beyond a few -- look at GigaOm by the way, a massive top 5 tech platform that is still looking for an out..it makes money sure but not enough to satisfy the endeavor and funding goal.

when someone declares that something is "over", its the time to start.

looking forward to seeing you do just that sarah

I have also this belief that we are surely entering the platinum era and are redefining blogosphere. The fact that sites like verge can still make their presence felt , is strong indication that there is still space for new quality blogs.And above all , "the content rules" principle will apply even 100 years from now.

Just. Getting. Started.

Hugely inspiring. Thanks for such a thoughtful piece, Sarah.

Sarah, as someone who blogs every day without getting paid for it (though I discover additional, intangible rewards as I go), I take a lot of courage from your rallying post. Thanks much!

The golden age of tech blogging is over?

Nooooooo! I cry, shaking my fist at an uncaring sky.

So many memories, so many golden age classic blog posts by dudes in Buddy Holly glasses writing so earnestly about stuff nobody gives a shit about anymore.

Please say it aint so.

I couldn't agree more with you. I think that blogging is just taking a new form. I also find that my clients blogs who are long and thoughtful get lots of traction and comments and conversation at cocktail parties.

Excellent post as always, Sarah. I hope all is well with you.

I've been a long time reader of yours, and long shared your passion for quality long-form web journalism.

If it's okay with you, I'd like to share some samples of my writing, as I'd love to join your new writing team. I can contribute highly literate, engaging and provocative articles on technology from a business perspective.

You can see some of my work on my general interest blog (the URL is in the header of this comment), but I also have other, longer journalistic pieces specifically focused on technology.

I'm an avid writer, technology aficionado and experienced business professional. You can reach me on my email address also in this comment header. I look forward to hearing from you. Meanwhile, I wish you and your family a very happy new year.

The comments to this entry are closed.

"Brilliant, Crazy, Cocky" puts a well-deserved spotlight on the fascinating entrepreneurs working in some of the most overlooked places on Earth. This book reminds us that when entrepreneurial opportunity is enabled and embraced locally, the economic and social benefits have the power to transform us all.
Brilliant. Crazy. Cocky.

New Book

An unforgettable portrait of the emerging world's entrepreneurial dynamos Brilliant, Crazy, Cocky is the story about that top 1% of people who do more to change their worlds through greed and ambition than politicians, NGOs and nonprofits ever can. This new breed of self-starter is taking local turmoil and turning it into opportunities, making millions, creating thousands of jobs and changing the face of modern entrepreneurship at the same time. To tell this story, Lacy spent forty weeks traveling through Asia, South America and Africa hunting down the most impressive up-and-comers the developed world has never heard of....yet.

Excerpt »

Buy it from these sellers

Srah Lacy

Sarah Lacy is an award-winning reporter who has covered high-growth entrepreneurship for more than fifteen years. She is the founder, CEO and Editor-in-Chief of PandoDaily.com, the site-of-record for the startup ecosystem. She lives in San Francisco.

Learn more »

Updates

Get updates delivered directly to your inbox. Just enter your email address and click Subscribe: